AAS Investigating Members?: Open Letter to the AAS Council

The following post provides the content of an Open Letter sent to the AAS Council, AAS AEB, and many AAS Committee members, by The Astronomy Underground (January 19, 2016).


 

Open Letter to the AAS AEB and AAS Leadership:

Through the AAS CSWA blog and the evidence revealed in the Geoff Marcy Title IX report, it has become clear that 1) AAS Committees have actively sought out information that might incriminate AAS members and 2) AAS Committees have interfered in and manipulated the affairs of university departments.

The Constitution of the AAS and the charges given to these committees make it clear that 1) Council has no mandate to engage in such actions, and that 2) the Committees are going beyond their scope.

The open public records release of Marcy documents and the AAS CSWA blog make it clear that Council cannot be ignorant of these actions. Council’s legal responsibility as Board members of a non-profit organization should make it clear to everyone that 1) Council is responsible for the oversight of the Committees of the AAS, 2) negligence is no excuse for wrongdoing, and 3) individual Council members are liable if their actions cause damage to the Society or to its members.

The January 2, 2016 letter from Timothy Slater makes it clear that Council was knowledgeable, and that Council was formally asked to address their lack of supervision/negligence of supervision of their Committees. Council has failed to respond.

On January 16, 2016, The Astronomy Underground posted emails that were leaked out of the AAS CSWA/AAS AEB social justice movement. It was revealed that AAS is again being used as a means to gather incriminating evidence about its members. Kim Coble of the AEB was listed as the point of contact for the AEB.

The Astronomy Underground also transmitted that the AAS was aware of this and is in the motions of creating a letter disavowing these efforts.

At this point, the AAS Council has been aware of what its Committees are doing for months. Disavowing these actions, when they are being done in the name of AAS, and AAS is aware, is not credible. AAS Council has either condoned these actions or has demonstrated negligence in their duties.

We ask AAS Council and the AEB to publicly explain how these actions have been allowed to occur for so long, and with what license AAS has acted to investigate its members, damaging their careers, their personal lives, and the health of the Society in the process.

We ask AAS to publicly explain how they intend to 1) repair the damage done to those who have been “investigated” under the AAS name, 2) redirect the astronomy experience for our youngest members who have now spent their entire careers focused on these matters rather than on the science, and 3) repair the reputation of astronomy on the national landscape, for the purposes of future recruitment and funding.

Your response, or lack thereof will be posted as an update to The Real Astronomy blog, a collaboration of international astronomers. We are concerned about the junior-astronomer and AAS focus on social engineering over the business of advancing our science.

-The Astronomy Underground

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s