We Stand Against Public Shaming

The following post has circulated in the underground of the astronomy community since October 2015, at the latest.  It has been passed along and repeatedly edited by astronomers, primarily young and female,  waiting for a publishing home where they wouldn’t be censored or shamed for their point of view.  This post is largely responsible for the existence of this website.  We thank the many women who contributed for inspiring the rest of us to action.


Over the last year the astronomy community has experienced several conflicts surrounding individual scientists (e.g. the biologist Tim Hunt and astronomers Matt Taylor, Shri Kulkarni and Geoff Marcy) who were accused for sexism and behavior hostile to women in physics and astronomy. These scientists were defamed over Twitter, Facebook and other social media.  A mobbing of these individuals has taken place, sometimes with strong consequences for their lives, far exceeding any of the damage that they have been accused of inflicting on others. This public shaming does not help gender equality but only shatters the relations between individual scientists. Organizations such as the Committee on the Status of Women in Astronomy have engaged, notoriously, in this activity. The friendship and atmosphere within the astronomical profession has suffered as a result.

While we agree with rational efforts to improve the astronomy community for all, we do not agree with the tactics used.

We take a stand FOR encouraging gender equality.

We take a stand FOR inventing measures that will help attract women to the field and help them stay within the field.

We take a stand FOR informing people about how biases influence the situation of women and,

We take a stand FOR the challenge of making our research field as gender equal as possible with constructive, peaceful measures.


We TAKE DISTANCE from social-media bullying and public shaming of individual scientists.

We TAKE DISTANCE from the Committee on the Status of Women in Astronomy as a group that represents women, feminists and the fight for gender equality, as long as they engage in these tactics.

We TAKE DISTANCE from the defamation of individual scientists over social media.

If a colleague does something against the law or the ethical boundaries of their university, it is strictly their local police or university administration that must make the decision how to deal with it. Social media is an inappropriate and irrational venue for managing these matters.

This reliance on appropriate administrations also demonstrates the diversity of cultures in our field and allow for each nation and each institution to set their own values and protocols.


3 thoughts on “We Stand Against Public Shaming

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s